Menorca vs Mallorca : which island should you choose for your trip?

Located in the Balearic Islands, these two Spanish Mediterranean gems are famous for their crystal-clear waters, turquoise coves and sunny way of life. But between Mallorca (the bigger, more varied island) vs Menorca (the wilder, more unspoilt one), the experience is quite different.

Each has its own character and strengths, so which one should you choose based on your travel style and wishes? Come aboard with us as we compare them from several angles (landscapes & nature, beaches, activities and accessibility) and, above all, how to make the most of them… from the water.

Geography & climate

Mallorca is the “big format” island: larger, more varied, with a real mix of coastline, countryside, villages and mountains. Its natural jewel is the Serra de Tramuntana, a mountain range listed as a UNESCO World Heritage Site.

Menorca, smaller and more protected, is easy to explore by “radiating out” from one base to another. The island is recognised for its ecosystems and its balance between human activity and the environment: it has been a UNESCO Biosphere Reserve since 1993.

In terms of climate, both islands share a classic Mediterranean feel: hot summers and mild winters. As a benchmark, sea temperature in Palma (Mallorca) averages around 13°C in February and 26°C in August.

Landscapes & things to do

Mallorca

Mallorca ticks a lot of boxes, especially if you want to alternate between sea and land. You can follow some stunning scenic roads and discover villages such as Valldemossa or Sóller.

Palma de Mallorca, the island’s “capital”, is absolutely worth a visit if you like combining culture and great food. The old town, with its historic streets, is packed with quality restaurants, modern galleries, lively markets and, of course, the famous Santa Maria cathedral. Finish the day watching the sunset along the seafront promenade.

❤️ Our favourite pick: Spend half a day with Oscar on his motorboat for an unforgettable trip along the Serra de Tramuntana coastline, a UNESCO World Heritage Site, and admire the cliffs from the sea.

Menorca

Menorca is ideal if your main goal is to slow down. With a more zen rhythm and a real “switch off” atmosphere, it’s perfect for nature walks and wild coves. On land, Ciutadella de Menorca on the west coast is the island’s charming former capital, with a historic centre around Plaça des Born and narrow streets lined with palaces, churches and pale-stone townhouses.

You’ll almost inevitably pass by Santa Maria Cathedral (yes, same name as in Mallorca), perched at the highest point of the town, before heading down to the natural harbour tucked into a small inlet, perfect for a drink at sunset before going back out to sea.

If you’re feeling more adventurous, the GR 223, also known as the Camí de Cavalls, is an iconic long-distance trail that loops right around the island. This 185-kilometre route offers a unique experience through a wide variety of dramatic landscapes and outstanding natural sites.

❤️ Our favourite pick: Head out with up to 8 people, with or without a skipper, on Raúl’s sailboat to discover Menorca’s spectacular coastline from the water.

Beaches

Mallorca really offers a bit of everything: long, easy-access beaches, picture-perfect coves, livelier spots… which is handy if your group has different expectations.

Menorca is almost synonymous with sheltered coves, translucent water and a more “nature-first” vibe. In summer, some spots get very busy on foot, which is exactly why experiencing them by boat makes such a difference.

On both islands, the winning strategy is the same: set off by boat to enjoy the very best shades of blue without the stress of parking, and choose your swimming stops according to sea conditions and the mood of the day.

Getting there & getting around

Both islands are well connected and easy to get around. Mallorca is larger, so travel times can be a little longer, but in return you get more options when it comes to accommodation, restaurants and activities.

Menorca is more compact, with shorter journeys and a smoother, more “fluid” feeling to the stay.

And if you still can’t decide, you don’t actually have to choose just one. The ferry from Alcúdia (Mallorca) to Ciutadella (Menorca) takes around 1h15 on some crossings, making a two-island itinerary perfectly realistic.

So, which island should you choose?

Choose Mallorca if your goal is maximum variety: villages, mountains, plenty of activities and, if you want it, a more festive side.

Choose Menorca if your plan is all about coves, calm, nature and a gentle pace – perfect for couples and families, and ideal for a truly relaxing break.

Honestly, you can’t really go wrong with either. Both are beautiful destinations. The most important thing is to be clear about your priorities and pick the island that best matches your wishes. With Click&Boat, you can rent a boat with or without a skipper and spend a carefree day on the water, one of the very best ways to enjoy these islands.

FAQ

Mallorca or Menorca: which island is best for a first visit?

If you want to “have it all” (beaches, villages, nightlife, activities), go for Mallorca. If you’re looking for a quieter, more nature-focused island, choose Menorca.

Which island is best for turquoise beaches and coves?

Both are stunning, but Menorca is often the favourite for its wild calas.

Which island is best for a family holiday?

Menorca is ideal for a more zen stay with short journeys and a gentle atmosphere. Mallorca is the better choice if you want more activity options and services.

Which island is livelier (restaurants, nightlife)?

Mallorca is clearly more vibrant and offers more places to go out, especially around Palma.

Can you visit both Mallorca and Menorca in one trip?

Yes. It’s perfectly doable, especially using the Alcúdia → Ciutadella ferry (around 1h15 on some routes), which makes a “two islands in one trip” itinerary very convenient.